This is a book and film comparison of the classic existential masterpiece ‘The Woman in the Dunes’. The story follows an entomologist who travels to a distant beach in search of rare insects. As the sun fades, villagers ask if he’d like to stay the night with them, but the protagonist is unaware that he’s about to be forced to live there against his will... The protagonist becomes caught between overcoming his situation by fighting for his liberty, or to acquiesce and accept his new life in the dunes. His predicament is rendered even more absurd when he is faced with the Sisyphean task of shovelling ceaseless torrents of sand that pervade every inch of the place where he now lives. 

For me, the film is actually much better than the book. Its music score, use of editing, and palpable visual representations of the environment depicting the horror of the inescapable sand all harmoniously work together to create an exceptional piece of art. The book too is good, but I felt it read as a little sexist compared to the film. This is probably due to the book being solely from the male’s perspective, whereas the film does a great job of balancing both the male’s and female’s perspectives. That being said, it is worth reading the book first to better understand some of the protagonist’s motivations and his backstory as they are explored in much greater detail. The one scene I did like better in the book was the quicksand scene. I felt this significant moment was slightly rushed in the film. 
But all in all, ‘The Woman in the Dunes’ is a wonderful work of philosophical fiction, and one of the 20th century’s best. 

Overall rating:
Book: 7/10
Film: 9/10

bradclacy
9
Écrit par

Créée

le 26 août 2019

Critique lue 104 fois

bradclacy

Écrit par

Critique lue 104 fois

D'autres avis sur La Femme du Sable

La Femme du Sable
Sergent_Pepper
9

Le grain et la peau.

[Série "Dans le top 10 de mes éclaireurs" : Amory, Confucius, Volte & Morrinson] Le prologue trompeur de La femme des sables nous met en prise avec un homme en pleine possession de ses moyens :...

le 13 sept. 2014

91 j'aime

15

La Femme du Sable
guyness
8

Les sables d’alone

Alors qu’à mon âge avancé et avec mon ancienneté ici je devrais commencer à jouer les vieux sages, je m’en fais encore régulièrement raconter par des petits jeunes venant tout juste de troquer le...

le 3 févr. 2014

60 j'aime

16

La Femme du Sable
SanFelice
10

Le sable y est

Considéré de nos jours comme un classique, Prix Spécial du Jury à Cannes en 1964, nommé pour l'Oscar du meilleur film étranger, La Femme des Sables, réalisation la plus célèbre de Hiroshi...

le 18 nov. 2016

54 j'aime

3

Du même critique

Le Décalogue
bradclacy
10

Philosophical masterpiece

This is my all time favourite series. Kieślowski brilliantly modernises each of the ten commandments by exploring the consequences and moral dilemmas that they bring about in contemporary society. He...

le 26 août 2019

1 j'aime

La Femme du Sable
bradclacy
9

Film/Book comparison

This is a book and film comparison of the classic existential masterpiece ‘The Woman in the Dunes’. The story follows an entomologist who travels to a distant beach in search of rare insects. As the...

le 26 août 2019

Vivre sa vie
bradclacy
9

Godard’s best

Jean-Luc Godard’s ‘Vivre Sa Vie’ stars the unforgettable Anna Karina, which follows her character’s descent into prostitution. This is a classic of the nouvelle vague, just like many of Godard’s...

le 26 août 2019